EYE ON DRACUT ~ Allison Volpe Struggles with Defeat in Dracut

By: Brian Genest – 10-26

After nearly 12 years on the Dracut School Committee, Allison Volpe still has a few things to learn. First, Volpe should understand that voters sometimes disagree with politicians. Also, sometimes the people you disagree with win. Last but not least, when the voters make a decision, elected officials are supposed to respect it. Apparently, that lesson hasn’t quite sunk in for Volpe.

At the School Committee’s meeting in late September, Selectman Chairman Don Plummer came to talk about Dracut’s continuing struggle to comply with the MBTA Communities law and the consequences for the town’s schools. It’s pretty simple: Dracut remains out of compliance. Attorney General Andrea Campbell is suing the town and Dracut is being denied state grants, including a $315,000 Early College Support Grant. Plummer came to explain the problem and ask the School Committee to support the revised zoning proposal that’s coming before Town Meeting in November.

The new proposal for the MBTA zones includes already-developed condominiums on Tennis Plaza Road and Merrimack Avenue, making compliance possible without necessarily producing the massive housing development critics feared. With the schools losing grant money because of the town’s non-compliance, you’d think this might be a good time for the town’s elected officials to work together. Instead, Volpe turned the discussion into another airing of grievances about the failed Campbell School project.

“I am shaking with rage right now,” Volpe told Plummer, before launching into a criticism of the Selectmen’s handling of the failed school project. When Plummer tried to explain that he had listened to the School Committee when it sought an MSBA extension, Volpe fired back. “OK. You listened but you didn’t take any action,” she said, before accusing him of coming back to the School Committee because he needed its support.

Then she kept going. Volpe complained that the Selectmen had not supported the School Committee’s proposal, demanded to know what the town was going to do to “get something done” and interrupted again after School Committee Chairman Rob Sheppard tried to bring the discussion back to the MBTA issue. At one point, Volpe declared that she hoped voters would “remember what’s really been going on in this town.”

That last part is worth remembering. So is the fact that Volpe’s own chairman and colleagues were trying to calm things down. Sheppard pointed out that Plummer had actually been invited by School Committee Member Dr. Rebecca Duda.

Duda thanked Plummer for coming and said she had reached out to him to begin the conversation. They were trying to have a discussion about how to keep students from losing educational opportunities; Volpe seemed determined to have another argument about a school the voters had already rejected.

That’s been the problem with the School Committee for the past year: a mindset that minimizes other departments, ignores shared responsibility and treats the town’s broader challenges as problems for someone else to solve. Under former Chairman Renée Young, the School Committee refused to meet with Selectmen without a paid mediator. The result was seven months of missed opportunities to engage with town leadership, an attempt to kill the school department audit and a governing style defined more by confrontation than cooperation.

When the voters had their say, Young lost all 10 precincts in her re-election bid and was thrown out of office. That wasn’t exactly a mixed message. It was a billboard. And it was because of a cumulative record of tone-deaf decisions, strained relationships and a refusal to meaningfully engage until political pressure forced it.

Yet the Campbell School fight has apparently become the political gift that keeps on giving. Even after voters rejected the $177 million project in June, some School Committee members, including Sheppard and Duda, continued looking for ways to revive it by seeking an MSBA extension that the Selectmen twice declined to pursue.

The voters said no. The Selectmen said no. And Volpe still seems to think somebody owes her an apology. That’s not how democracy works. And it’s not a great example for the kids, either.

There’s nothing wrong with fighting for the schools or disagreeing with the Selectmen. But there’s a difference between standing up for your position and repeatedly treating everyone who disagrees with you as though they’ve somehow failed the town. At some point, elected officials have to govern the town they actually have, not the one they wish voters had approved.

That applies to MBTA compliance, too. When Volpe questioned whether the revised zoning plan addressed affordable housing, Plummer explained that the MBTA Communities law is a zoning mandate, not an affordable-housing mandate. Volpe eventually conceded with a quiet, “Fair enough.”

Duda later said the School Committee has a responsibility to move forward because the town’s non-compliance is affecting educational opportunities for Dracut students. She and Sheppard talked about collaboration between the two boards. Then, Duda summed up the obvious solution: “It’s time to move on.”

Exactly.

The Campbell School was rejected by the voters. The Selectmen made their decision about the MSBA extension. The town has moved on to the next set of problems and priorities. Volpe hasn’t.

When Volpe’s up for reelection, voters will decide whether her version of leadership — combative, emotional and apparently unable to let a political defeat stay defeated — is what they want representing them. They may remember the unnecessary and prolonged drama over the Campbell School vote. They may remember the September meeting when the School Committee tried to move on. And they may remember Allison Volpe yelling into the microphone — telling them to remember what’s been going on in town — while shaking with rage.

— Brian Genest is the producer and host of Eye On Dracut, winner of the Hometown Media Award for news. Watch online at facebook.com/EyeOnDracut. ◊