Home Equity Theft is and Has Been Unconstitutional!

8-24

Because of the Supreme Court decision in Tyler v. Hennepin County, Massachusetts is now trying to get credit for what never should have been taken from property owners in excess of their tax debt.

But Massachusetts has been getting away with violating the 5th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Massachusetts Declaration of Rights – Article 10.

Gov. Healey signed an attachment to the fiscal year 2025 budget banning municipalities from taking the entire equity in a home in the event of a tax-lien foreclosure but included a 3-year statute of limitations.

Sen. Mark Montigny said he first filed the bill in 2018 to protect homeowners from so-called “equity theft”, the issue has grabbed more headlines following the Supreme Court’s ruling almost a year ago. Massachusetts law Ch. 60 allowed a city or town to foreclose on a person’s house to pay a tax debt, then keep the full value of the real estate beyond the amount of the debt. In April 2024 state Judge M. Callen ruled the Massachusetts law governing municipal home equity takings “requires Legislative correction.”

On March 21, 2024, Pacific Legal wrote that “the Court held that home equity theft—when the government takes more than is owed when collecting a property tax debt—is unconstitutional.”

But what about people like Gracemarie and Joyce Tomaselli, 2 seniors, who owned Registered and Recorded property at Salisbury Beach, who are not being given the same opportunity to be compensated by the Town of Salisbury for the town’s home equity theft?

On July 5, 2002, the Tomaselli sisters handed over a check to the Town of Salisbury Manager in the amount of $15,492.04 to bring them current, to allow them to obtain their restaurant licenses to reopen Mangia … a Café-Restaurant on the property in dispute.

The Town accepted the check but never cashed it. The Valley Patriot wrote about this on valleypatriot.com. They had difficulty in the courts in their attempt to remove incorrect tax charges, which went into land court for the tax taking $45,000 for the building and $5,000 for the marsh lot for sewer betterment/assessments that according to MGL Ch. 80 and Ch. 83 they did not owe, and excessive incorrectly calculated sewer user fees, plus 16% interest, and penalties imposed as “taxes” by the Town of Salisbury, plus the Town’s attorneys’ fees, etc. amounting to $251,000 in Judge Gordon H. Piper’s Land Court decision.

The Tomasellis tried many courts through the many years to correct the Town’s extremely excessive and incorrect tax and sewer charges but to no avail culminating in a tax taking, and auction of their property.

The Town prevailed to take Tomaselli’s home/property using the courts and with the aid of the town attorneys who concealed relevant evidence and committed fraud on all the courts. The Town auctioned the Salisbury Beach property for $775,000.00 and didn’t give them the remaining equity!

This statute of limitations imposed by Massachusetts has cost the Tomaselli sisters approximately $524,000. A 3- year statute of limitations is unjust for an unconstitutional taking.