OPINION: Chief Justice Kimberly Budd Doubled Down On Her Anti-American Defiance

By: Dr. Bharani Padmanabhan, MD., PHD
9/25

Defiance of the United States defines those with innate contempt for the American Revolution and the bedrock principles that define this unique republic. Defiance is different from protected expressive conduct such as flag-burning.

Defiance is the wholesale rejection of the fundamental principles that define the United States, such as equality under the law, protecting recognized American rights, acknowledging the supremacy of the US Constitution and US Supreme Court precedents. You know, basic stuff that all ordinary Americans automatically take as the norm.

And then we have Massachusetts judges.

The Valley Patriot has reported on the anti-American Soviet show trials in the state’s medical board and I have filed court briefs on the open contempt shown by both bureaucrats and the judiciary to US Supreme Court precedents that recognized bedrock American rights, including the 200-foot No Speech Zone around the Karen Read trial.
Massachusetts judges are properly described as counter-revolutionaries with innate contempt for ordinary Americans and everything they hold dear.

This has resulted in stinging bench slaps from the US Supreme Court. In McCullen v. Coakley the court destroyed Massachusetts’ innate contempt for the 1st Amendment. Remember, Massachusetts convicted bookseller Abraham Isenstadt for selling Lillian Smith’s Strange Fruit and refuses to vacate it.

In Caetano the Court condemned the SJC’s contempt for the people and the 2nd Amendment. In Melendez-Diaz the Court slammed the SJC for its contempt for the 6th Amendment. The SJC refused to overrule its own anti-American Roberts v. Boston and instead relied on it for 65 years to violate the 5th and 14th Amendments.

Massachusetts judges openly defy the US Supreme Court’s orders. On June 23, 2025, Judge Brian Murphy declared that his order remained in force “notwithstanding” the US Supreme Court vacating it. The Court had to shout that defiance is unlawful. Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D, 606 U.S. __ (2025)(July 3, 2025)
Barely two weeks later the Court was again forced to condemn Judge William Young for his defiance.

“Lower court judges may sometimes disagree with this Court’s decisions, but they are never free to defy them….

And either way, when this Court issues a decision, it constitutes a precedent that commands respect in lower courts.” National Institutes of Health v. American Public Health Assn., 25A103.

CJ Kimberly Budd defied a binding precedent celebrated by immigration advocates which recognized the right of everyone in the United States to earn a living in his or her profession and that this right shall not be destroyed. Truax v. Raich, 239 US 33 (1915)
If one did not know the anti-American counter-revolutionary core of Massachusetts judges, this would be a surprise.

I briefed Budd that she defied a right that defines the United States. Unlike Judge Young who publicly apologized, Budd doubled down on her hatred for the United States, the SJC’s own precedent in Foxworth v. St. Amand, 457 Mass. 200 (2010), and the people’s law, Ch. 211A § 10, that imposes a duty upon her. Instead, Budd showed everyone a middle finger via UPPER CASE letters. (https://www.ma-appellatecourts.org/docket/SJC-13760)

Now Budd’s anti-American core is crystal clear with the sharp lines of a pop art painting. The legislature should impeach her, but that requires them to love the United States too.

Bharani Padmanabhan MD PhD is a neurologist. scleroplex@gmail.com ◊